Title - A Matter of Trust Author - Aris "TGD" Merquoni E-Mail - aris@sandwich.net Rating - R Category - SA Spoilers - 'Pusher', but nothing worth mentioning. Keywords - None Summary - A Four-scene look at the dark side of life, as a case Mulder and Scully are working on takes a drastic turn. Mulder ends up shirtless and in pain twice. Archive - Heh, if you want to, go ahead. Disclaimer: Not mine. Mulder, Scully, etc == 1013, CC's. Gardener is based on Pittsburg's poem "Megan Ann Gardner" for no better reason than I hate making up names. Geoff Trenchard and his poetry belong to him. Author's Note: This story is a travesty. I'm calling it that now so you won't have to do it later, and you can just sit back and enjoy it without worrying about what names to come up with. It was written in self defense of my sanity, i.e. because my Muse wanted me to. This is not the first piece of X-Files fanfic that I've written, but it's the first I've *published.* This story is coded as indicated in that block up there for you actual X-Philes, and [F/M/F s/m b/d nc reluc] for those of you who know what I'm talking about. If you don't, that's probably a good indicator that you're going to be shocked by this story. Or at least worried about *me*. This story *is*, despite all outward appearances, probably acceptable to people under the age of 18(Physically, not mentally.) However, I'm issuing a blanket warning in order to CMA: this is not kiddie stuff. Hell, it's not like warnings'll keep you out, anyway, so don't blame me if this scars your childhood forever. Other than that? It's psychological. I'm really into the shrink thing. I'm *not*, however, into the angst thing. This isn't your normal muldertorture.com story. If you still enjoy it after all of that(or want to rip me to shreds; that's good too,) my e-mail is aris@sandwich.net. -- =* A Matter of Trust *= -- "I just don't think you should go there by yourself, that's all," Scully said from the other side of the room. Mulder looked up and smiled reprovingly at her. "This is the first break we've had on this case, and we need to take it." "But alone? Mulder, you don't know what this person could be hiding. They might not have anything on Gardener at all." "And they very well *might*," he said, checking his gun and then the clock for the fifteenth time this minute. "You remember what that girl looked like when Gardener got done with her. Not to mention the two that weren't so lucky." Scully shuddered, and he had to fight down the shakes himself. Kids *shouldn't* be treated like that, come out of an adult's hands covered in slashes from kitchen knives, broken beer bottles, whatever. And the two that hadn't survived... "I *do* remember," Scully finally said, jerking him out of his reverie. "And that's why I don't want you going." He pulled himself up and gave her a look. "Scully. I'm hardly a twelve-year-old kid." "Yeah?" She leaned back in her chair and glared. "I'll give you that. But what was that I heard about 'testing a theory about telepathy'?" Mulder grimaced. Caught. "Well..." "Come on. I heard you muttering that she must have been 'controlling' them in some way." She crossed one leg over the other and drew tiny circles in the air with her toe. He frowned. "Well, think about it. You heard that girl... Gardener made her want to go back. That's not just psychological twisting. If Gardener really has the kind of telepathy that Modell-" "Don't-" Scully said, putting up a hand, "Don't mention Modell." "I have to, Scully. You *saw* how Modell could control people. If Gardener can do the same thing, she's more of a threat than we thought. And if I can learn *anything* from this meeting," he glanced at the clock, "To which I will be late if I don't get going-" "Mulder..." "Then maybe we can figure out how to stop her." "But why do you have to go in *alone?*" He stopped pacing, then crossed the room and rested a hand on her shoulder. "Because the invitation was for me, alone. I want you there to back me up, not to scare whoever this is away." "Now you're making sense." "Yeah, and you're going to hate me for the next bit. I want you to drop me off at this hotel, and then leave for at least ten minutes. I need to talk to this person alone." Scully glowered, but finally nodded. "All right. I still think I should come in with you." "It should be fine." He held up the room key that'd been in the envelope with the note. "I know what I'm doing." She followed him to the car, shaking her head as he pocketed the room key for his own room. "I trust you, Mulder, but... I still think you're making a mistake here." "Well, you can tell me 'I told you so' if you save my ass again, okay?" He grinned as he opened the car door. "Trust me, Scully. This will go fine. Then we can finish this case and get back to spooky patrol stuff, right?" "Sure, Mulder," she said, climbing in beside him. "Whatever you say." -- "Ten minutes are up," Scully said under her breath as she pulled the car into a parking space. "Here I come, ready or not." The night air was the temperature normally called 'crisp', but there was nothing crisp in the murky clouds sliding over the moon. She glanced up, shuddered, then headed for the stairway that Mulder had dissapeared into just ten minutes before. It was an outside-leading-inside deal, something to keep the lower level from being disturbed. Or something. The door outside closed behind her as she felt her way up the flight. Scully could smell blood as soon as she got up the stairs. The fact that she could worried her. Being able to actually smell the rusty tang meant a lot of blood had been spilled, close by, and she wasn't yet sure if it was her partner's or not. The hallway leading off from the stairway was dingy, the kind of carpeting and lighting she'd expect in a cheap hotel during a power outage. There was a cracked window at the end of the row of doors, letting in enough light that she didn't need to use the flashlight. Yet. Someone cried out. Scully froze in place, one more shadow in the dark hallway, then moved forward. Was it her, or did that sound like... Mulder? Then there was another voice, female, but she couldn't make out the words. Following the voice, Scully made her way down the hallway. Not this door... not this one... it was nearly to the end of the row by the time she heard the second cry, and found the door. She hesitated only a moment before putting her gun to the wood and trying the handle. To her surprise, the door opened smoothly, widening to reveal a room that was lit only slightly better than the hallway by a single lamp in the far corner. A woman was standing across the room from the door, and as Scully stepped inside she turned around and smiled. Black, thick, curly hair framed exotic eyes, a perfect complexion, and rich red lips, spilling over the shoulders of the woman who Scully recognized at once. "Annette Gardener," she said in an even voice, "You are under arrest for three counts of kidnapping and two counts of first-degree murder, plus whatever else we can find to stick on you." The smile widened into a shark's grin. "I don't think you want to do that, Agent Scully," she said slowly, then tilted her head at the bed behind her. Scully looked past the woman and froze, her heart suddenly a lot closer to her throat than she wanted. Mulder was sprawled face-up on the bed, and after a moment her eyes picked out the ropes attaching his wrists and ankles to the metal posts at the four corners of the matress. His jacket and shirt had been lost somewhere, and at the moment he was staring at his partner with a wild, almost frightened gaze. It was then that Scully saw the shard of glass that Gardener was holding at his throat, and with a jolt she realized where the smell of blood was coming from. There had to be at least a hundred tiny slashes covering Mulder's chest, stomach, and arms, and as she watched the woman changed her grip ever so slightly and drew a thin line in blood on Mulder's collarbone. "Stop," Scully said, as Mulder grimaced in pain and leaned his head back to the matress. Her hands were shaking, so she took a tighter grip on her pistol. "Stop, now." The smile was back. "All good things must end, I guess," Gardener said with an affected sigh. "But I really think we should ask *his* opinion, shouldn't we?" Scully involuntarily looked back at her partner. Mulder's eyes were open again, and he looked... worried? Frightened? "What do you think, hmm?" the woman said, pulling the shard of glass further down his chest. Mulder's hands clenched around the ropes holding him down, and his breath hissed through his teeth. "I don't think you mind this at all. I think you kind of... like it." "Mulder, what's going on?" Scully said, feeling more and more out of synch with every passing moment. "Tell me to stop and I will," Gardener said, reaching up to hold the shard of glass above Mulder's right arm. She looked up and smiled at Scully. "What do you think, Fox? Do you want me to stop?" Scully waited for a timeless instant, trapped in Gardener's eyes. A second passed. Another. The silence stretched on, thick with the smell of Mulder's blood hanging in the air. "Mulder?" Scully finally whispered. "Mulder, say something... please, say something..." Gardener chuckled, and brought the shard of glass down on Mulder's arm. A moan escaped his throat as she traced the inside of his elbow, then pulled the glass away. Then she looked up to meet Scully's gaze, and smiled wider. "Is it so hard to understand?" she said. "Sometimes, it's good to feel... helpless. Hurt." She reached back and negligently opened another cut on Mulder's side. "Or both. What do you think, Fox?" "Mulder, no..." Scully said. "Oh, yes. Come on, Foxy, tell us what you think. Do you like what I'm doing to you?" Mulder met Scully's eyes again, and she could read fear, easy enough, and something else, too, that worried her more. Gardener gave him another slice, then purred, "Tell me, Fox. Tell me... or I'll stop." Scully felt something inside her clench in fear. Mulder's gaze was panicked, now. As if he wanted to say something, but couldn't. Or if he didn't want to say something, but knew he was going to. No. She couldn't admit that. "Tell me, Fox Mulder," Gardener said, holding the bloody glass over his stomach. "You can say yes, can't you? Or I'll stop." His mouth moved, but no sound came out. Gardener wasn't satisfied. "Louder. Louder, Fox, I can't hear you." "Yes," he said, voice choked, then closed his eyes in pain and leaned his head back. "Yes, dammit!" Scully staggered as if she'd been punched. Gardener's eyes gleamed in triumph, and she brought the shard of glass down again and again- And then stopped. Straightening, she crossed the room and pulled the gun from Scully's unresisting fingers. "No, no," she said quietly. "This isn't quite right." Scully found herself pushed forward, stumbling to a halt next to the bed. Looking down to where her partner was bound hand and foot, blood welling from a hundred wounds, she felt a wave of vertigo sweep over her. "What do you think, Fox?" Gardener said from two inches and a million miles away, "Don't you think *she* should be doing this, and not me?" Mulder lifted his head as if in a daze, and Scully shuddered. She was *not* seeing ... not just fear, but... No. She refused to consider it. He stared at her, eyes barely focusing, and Scully felt the shard of glass being pressed into her hand. "Come on, Fox. You want it. Tell her." He swallowed, but said nothing. Scully shuddered, fingers clenching around the smooth piece of glass. "Come *on,* Fox," Gardener said again. "Don't you know how to ask?" After a pause, she said, "You have to be polite. You have to say please." He flinched. Scully reached out a hand--the other hand-- not the one with the shard. "Mulder..." "Oh, God," he said. "Mulder, you don't-" Scully said, desperate. "Please," he whispered. Scully stared at him, then let her eyes drop to the alien thing in her hand. Slowly, shaking, she raised it to the light. He watched, then caught her eye again. "Please," he said, clearer, desperation edging out the fear. "Oh, God, Dana, please..." She stared at him, stared as if she didn't know him, as if she didn't know herself. And just as if she didn't know herself, her own hand, she watched as she lowered the sharp and bloody piece of glass to his stomach and drew a clear line across his skin in red. Mulder moaned, his head rolling back, and Scully pulled away, then as though she had no choice reached forward again and drew another line across his chest. Just like drawing lines, she told herself, just drawing lines in red, with red ink, only her pen was pain and the ink was blood and the words she wrote she refused to read. She didn't even notice Annette Gardener leaving as she reached out again and again to carve divine instructions in her partner's flesh. She was too busy trying to ignore the look on Mulder's face every time she sank the shard of glass into his skin, just deep enough to cause him to bleed. She told herself that it wasn't real, that it wasn't really *Mulder*, or that he hadn't really said anything, just to keep herself together. She told herself it was all pain that was causing him to grab the ropes that bound him so hard that they creaked, that they'd been brainwashed somehow, that it was all Gardener's fault and nothing else. And she told herself it was just with pain that he finally cried out, causing her to drop the piece of glass and watch it skitter across the floor, leaving bloodstains on the dirty wooden slats. She told herself that it was just pain over and over again as she stood there shaking, eyes shut tight and hands clenched into fists at her sides. "Scully?" Very slowly, she opened her eyes. Mulder was looking at her, eyes clear again and expression slightly embarassed, slightly chagrined, but mostly completely lost. "I... I... can you help me out of this?" he said, pulling at the ropes. She nodded, then reached forward and started untying his closest hand. He nodded thanks when she'd got the knot loosened, and reached over to get the other side while she worked on his ankles. He sat there rubbing his wrists to get the circulation back while she freed both his legs, and then they both stayed still, staring at each other and unsure how to proceed. "I..." he said, then nodded past her. "There's a bathroom over there. I'm going to clean off." He said it perfectly normally, as if it was just dirt and not blood he was covered in. Blood, and... Scully sat down on the bed as he passed her, arms wrapped around herself to keep from shaking. God. No. It just wasn't... no. There was the sound of a tap running, and the door closed. Scully sat, rocking slowly, until the water shut off. Mulder opened the door and stood there, the same lost look on his face. "Ah... have you seen my shirt anywhere?" he said. Scully looked down and saw it by her feet. She picked it up and crossed the short distance to hand it to him. He took it, then looked up to meet her eyes. "I... I owe you an apology," he said. She shook her head. "Look... it doesn't matter, now." "It does. I didn't know what was going to happen. I just thought... I thought I could bring this file to a close. I didn't know she was going to-" "Let's just forget it," Scully said, the panic and the shock of the whole situation pressing into her voice. "Let's just go back home and forget this ever happened." "No, Dana, we can't," he said quietly, hands curled up in his shirt. "Mulder-" "We can't, because even if we don't say anything, this is going to be between us." "We can just-" "Because *you'll* still have to face up to the fact that you sat there cutting me up, and I *liked* it." Scully flinched as if he'd struck her, and curled up against the doorframe. After a moment of silence she felt a tenative touch on her shoulder. "Dana?" he said quietly. "I'm... I'm sorry." "God, Fox," she managed to say, "Why?" He took a deep breath. "If I knew that," he said, "I'd open a psychiatric institution, solve all the world's problems, become a trillionaire, and then solve all the *rest* of the world's problems, starting with my own." She turned around, pressing her spine hard against the doorjam. Mulder was staring at her, his deep, soulful eyes wide with pain. Scully realized with a shock that she'd hurt him somehow. And not by... by... God. If she couldn't even think about it... "Scully, I didn't know," he said. "Please believe me, I didn't *know*." "Didn't know what?" she said, her voice sounding choked even to her ears. Mulder didn't answer. He looked down and saw he was still clenching his fist around the fabric, and loosened his fingers to pull the shirt on over the network of cuts covering his chest. As he buttoned the front of the shirt with his typical methodical precision, Scully realized that he didn't know the answer himself. When he'd finished, he wouldn't look up to meet her eyes. She hesitated a long moment, perhaps longer than she should have, before she reached out to put a hand on his arm. "Mulder, I..." He looked up again, and this time there was real fear in his eyes. She held his gaze for half an eternity, then stepped forward and pulled him close, feeling his arms wrap around her, holding onto her for dear life. He was tall enough to rest his head on hers, and she was completely enveloped by his embrace, close enough to still smell the blood. -- "Are you sure you'll be all right?" Mulder nodded, mustered up enough courage to look his partner in the eye. "Yeah, I'll be fine," he said, but he was sure she'd see it for the lie it was. She nodded hesitantly at his halfhearted smile, but then, everything about her had seemed hesitant tonight. He'd managed to scare her, somehow. No, not 'somehow,' he knew damn well 'how.' It was the same way he'd managed to scare himself. "All right. I'll see you tomorrow," she finally said. He nodded and closed the door, then leaned on it. Dingy hotels, quiet and dark rooms--the images floated past his eyes until he reached out and, groping blindly in the half-darkness of the room, hit the light switch. Click, and he was back in reality, standing in a hotel room holding a bag full of bactine and gauze padding. Right. Bactine and gauze. His chest still hurt like hell from--don't think about it. Toss the jacket on the chair, right, one less thing to worry about. He went into the bathroom, hit the light there, didn't look at his reflection as he unbuttoned his shirt. Finally had to look up when he'd got the antiseptic on the pad. No, he didn't need a doctor to dab the stinging solution on the cuts. *But you'd like one,* his subconscious whispered as he swabbed his collarbone and moved on to his shoulders, *You'd like it to be Dana, here, tending to your wounds, making everything hurt just a little-* "Dammit," he swore, pushing down too hard on one of the cuts and rubbing the antiseptic in. It hurt like hell. Not enough, though. Not enough to erase the shame. Not enough to bring it back. God, what had he *done* to her? Not what had he done to himself. That was messed up enough that he didn't want to think about it. *He* was messed up enough that he didn't want to think about it. But Scully... Scully was normal. Scully was composed, controlled... focused. Capable. And God damn it if every time he thought about her he envisioned her running a scalpel down his side, just enough to- He hissed again as he scratched too deeply on a cut on his stomach, starting it bleeding again. The bactine leaked into the cut, making it sting enough to bring him around, back to staring at his own muddy hazel eyes in the halfway-decent light. Damn it. Damn. It. What was it about her that was making him think--what was it about *him* that was making him think--Dammit. He'd scared her. He'd screwed up, listened to Gardener for one fatal instant and then betrayed any trust Scully had for him. He finished swabbing the last few cuts, then gave up and leaned on the sink, resting his forehead agaisnt the mirror. God. He wished he could just crawl down into a dark, festering hole and- At first he thought the pain was from his breath catching, or his breath catching from some psychosomatic illness brought on by self-loathing. He was surprised, but hardly worried, when he saw the blood trickling from just blow his ribs into the sink. It wasn't until he tried to breathe again and felt the pain hit him that he registered the knife point sticking out of his front. He looked up. Someone met his eyes in the mirror. He labored to say her name, but he couldn't breathe, couldn't get air, it hurt, it hurt... "Can you feel your life slipping away, Fox?" Gardener whispered as his mind raced, wondering how the hell did she get in the key was in your pocket you idiot Scully let you in Scully doesn't know Gardener has the key would Scully even save him now if she knew he could trust her would she trust him too? "Can you feel it? Everything soon fading... to black?" She leaned forward and the knife--knife, hell, half a sword it felt like--slid farther through him, the steel coming out coated in blood. His blood. His fingers curled around the point of the blade as crazy thoughts--*Where did Gardener get a hold of a wakizashi?*--flitted through his head. Gardener stepped forward, pressing against his back. He could feel her breasts through the thin, filmy fabric of her shirt, and he gritted his teeth to keep from lashing out in anger. It was bad enough with her voice playing tricks with his mind, but this... it was almost enough to make him cry out, 'Yes, yes, dammit, I *do* want to die...' "Your vision will go grey, then black," she murmured sweetly into his ear. "You'll slide down that mortal coil, back into the welcoming arms of nothingness... you will never hurt again... feel how lovely it is for your life to slip through your fingers... drop... by... drop." Every 'drop' was another push on the knife. By the time she was through, the cold metal handle was pressed fully against his back, her hand caressing the torn flesh around the steel. She reached around him with both arms and smeared blood across his chest, over the hundreds of tiny red lines already on his skin. "Give in," she said. "You want this, don't you? You want me," she paused, voice dropping to a whisper as she leaned forward to blow in his ear, "to bring you death." Oh, but it felt so good to just give in... It would feel so good to just let her have total control, let go and listen to her sensual voice as she guided him down the dark, dark tunnel into the eternal silence... yes, yes, you bitch, please, make me bleed, it feels so good... The outer door opened. Gardener blinked, then pulled back and looked out into the main room. Mulder took as deep a breath as he could manage, and forced his voice to work. "Scully?" Gardener's head was jerked back around. "You're not *supposed* to," she hissed in shock, "You're not supposed to want-" *=- "And it didn't sound... that hard... it just sounded loud. Like knuckles popping underwater kind of loud. Like people breaking bones you've broken kind of loud. Like a real gunshot... real close by kind of loud." -- Geoff Trenchard, _Hundred Line Stare_ -=* Gardener staggered, no longer perfectly calm and collected, and collapsed face-down onto the bathroom floor. Mulder held onto the knifepoint with one hand and the sink in the other and prayed his legs wouldn't give out. They did, eventually, but Dana was there, holding onto him, strong for all she looked so small, easing him down onto the floor and some towels she'd swiped to make padding. Dana was there to hold onto him, elevate his legs to treat his shock, to call 911 on her cellphone so she wouldn't have to leave his side. Dana was there to hold onto him and call his name so he wouldn't pass out. And she was there when he did finally pass out, strapped sideways to the gurney with the oxygen mask over his face obscuring his view of the dark night outside. -- Mulder's eyes finally opened again three days later. Scully thought it was just a trick of the light, but as she watched his eyelids fluttered again, then with a heartbreaking slowness opened to reveal muddy, confuzed hazel eyes. "Mulder?" she whispered, not wanting to balance too much hope on that one word. He focused on her unsteadily, then his eyes flickered around the room. "Scully..." he wheezed, then made a face as he held back a cough. "Tubes," he finally said. "Yeah." Scully reached out and rested a hand on his arm. "I figured you'd notice that." "Hate tubes," he muttered, then twitched his mouth in a wry smile. "But... guess it's necessary. How bad?" "Bad enough," she said. "That knife punctured your lung. Not to mention some other internal organs of slightly lesser importance." Mulder winced and let his head lie back on the pillow again. He'd been silent for so long Scully thought he'd gone to sleep when he said, "Scully? Can... can you ever forgive me?" "Oh, Mulder..." she leaned forward to meet his eyes, then reached out and brushed a few errant strands of hair off his forehead. "I *trust* you. With my life. I don't know..." she took a deep breath. "Give me some time, all right? I forgive you. I just..." The full force of all the confusion and pain she'd felt over the last few days hit her, and she was sure he could see it. "Give me some time," she said again. "I'll try... and understand, okay?" He smiled at her sadly, then closed his eyes and leaned back into the pillow. "That's all right, then," he said. Scully fought with herself to keep from straightening his hair again--it'd turn into an obsessive-compulsive disorder if she wasn't careful. After a few more moments of silence, she was sure he was asleep again. Making sure to keep quiet she stood, then turned to go. "She was right, you know," Mulder said, voice suddenly strong. Scully turned back to him. "What?" "Gardener. She was right." His voice trailed off, became more dreamlike. "Sometimes it is good to feel... helpless... lose control... let someone do things for you..." There was a long pause. "But even then... I didn't want to die... No matter how good she made it feel." Scully couldn't keep herself from shuddering as she closed the door behind her. -- =* Finis *= -- A-one, Two, A-one two three Four... Some love is just a lie of the heart The cold remains of what began with a passionate start And they may not want it to end But it will it's just a question of when I've lived long enough to have learned The closer you get to the fire the more you get burned But that won't happen to us Because it's always been a matter of trust I know you're an emotional girl It took a lot for you to not lose your faith in this world And I can't offer you proof But you're going to face a moment of truth It's hard when you're always afraid You'll just recover when another belief is betrayed So break my heart if you must It's a matter of trust You can't go the distance with too much resistance I know you'll have doubts - But for God's sake, don't shut me out! This time you've got nothing to lose You can take it you can leave it's whatever you choose I won't hold back anything And I'll walk away a fool or a king Some love is just a lie of the mind It's make believe until it's only a matter of time And some might have learned to adjust But then, it never was a matter of trust... I'm sure you're aware, love, we've both had our share of Believing too long, when the whole situation was wrong Some love is just a lie of the soul A constant battle for the ultimate state of control After you've heard lie upon lie There can hardly be a question of 'why' Some love is just a lie of the heart The cold remains of what began with a passionate start But that won't happen to us Because it's always been a matter of trust It's a matter of trust... -- _A Matter of Trust_, Billy Joel